Red Skull Incarnate

Here's where you report issue analyses of any issue in any universe or timeline.

Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb

Locked
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1443
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

Red Skull Incarnate

Post by Leoparis »

#1
Nov 1923
Johann Schmidt as a boy in Munich (born in 1914), he sees Hitler during the putsch and kills dogs while working for a dogcatcher.
(Pak doesn't follow the birth date of 1899 given by DeMatteis in #298, which was anyway very early for Schmidt being a bellboy and trained as a soldier in the 30s)

#2
Berlin, Nov 1926
Johann finds haven from a Jewish shopowner and his daughter Emmy.
In March 1927 while the family is attacked he kills another boy and steals the cash.

#3
Berlin 1933 p 1-7 Schmidt following the orders of Beckert murders a nazi. Later he meets Dieter who is now a communist
Feb 23 p 8-9 A rally is canceled, Johann and Dieter
Feb 25 p 10 Beckert advises Johann to kill Dieter
Feb 27 p 11-15 Johann tries to get Dieter to kill Beckert, Reichstag is burned
p 16 Hitler enforces a state of emergency
p 17-18 Johann watches as Dieter is beaten by Nazis
p 19 Germany events March-June 1933
p 20 Johann joins the nazi party between Jan and May 1933

#4
Sept 1933 1-15 Johann at Nuremberg watching Hitler and Röhm. He's in the SA but wants to join the SS. However they make fun of him and beat him up.
p 12-13, 15 Max Eisenhardt and his father appear (to be included in Magneto's chronology)

Three months later
p 16 Dieter Lehmann is released from Dachau at Christmas after having been sent there for reeducation
p 17-20 Johann bursts on a communist meeting between Dieter and two friends and announces they're going to kill Hitler

#5
Munich June 29, 1934
pp 1-4 Johann kills his former officer in the SA
Bad Wiessee, later that day
pp 5-7 Johann and Dieter infiltrate the Hotel Dieter dresses as bellhop
pp 8-11 The attempt is thwarted as the SS round up and kill the SA
pp 12-13 Johann and Dieter exchange costumes
pp 14-18 They go to Hitler's room, bringing food. Dieter pulls a gun on Hitler, Johann stops and kills Dieter before he understands what's happening. Hitler looks at Johann and asks his men to release him.
pp 19-20 SA cleanup continues. Röhm is killed (2 July 1934), Johann in SS uniform beside Hitler.

Hitler appearances:
Nov 1923 Red Skull 1
Feb 7 1933 Red Skull 3
Sept 1933 Hitler at Nuremberg Red Skull 4
29 June 1934 Night of the Long Knives Red Skull 5
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1443
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

Post by Leoparis »

Trying to mesh Incarnate with ToS #66 (I don't have Cap #298)

Red Skull #1, 1923 Johann is nine, leaves the Home for wayward boys

ToS #66 p 3 pn1-2 Johann steals chicken but gets beaten up and stolen in turn

Red Skull #2 Nov 1926, Johann steals apple but gets beaten up and stolen in turn, fights back with a knife
taken over by a jew shopkeeper and his daughter Emmy (maybe the same as Cap #298)
Mar 1927 abandons the jew family (unsure whether he kills the girl)

ToS #66 p3 pn 3-5 (this last panel shows a tavern owner and a young woman)

Red Skull #3, Early 1933, Rise of nazi party to power, Johann joins the SA
(ToS #66 p 3, pn 3 shows Nazis clearing a square, as on p 8 but this isn't necessarily the same)

Red Skull #4 Late 1933, Johann reconnects with Dieter

ToS #66 p4 pn 4 doesn't exist, it shows the bellboy looking at a nazi meeting; Johann as a SA looked at a nazi meeting in Nuremberg in Red Skull #3

Red Skull #5 June 29, 1934
pages 1-13 Johann and Dieter go to Rohm's hotel
p 14 pn 1 (=ToS #66 p4 pn 5) Johann as bellboy (with Dieter) brings a platter
p 14 pn 2 They enter the room
p 14 pn 3 (=ToS #66 p5 pn1) He puts the platter on the table
p 14 pn 4 - p 18 Johann foils Dieter's assassination attempt
(ToS #66 p 5 pn 3-5 Hitler decides to recruit Schmidt)
p 19-20 Schmidt in SS uniform as bodyguard to Hitler in the wake of the Night of Long Knives)
Zemo Born Better #3-4 (Schmidt as Hitler's bodyguard)
(ToS #66 p 5 pn 6-7 - p 7 Hitler dissatisfied with Schmidt's training, turns him into Red Skull)

I moved around the Born Better issues to before he became the costumed Red Skull.

In addition the cover of Red Skull 4, dated March 16, 1939 tells us that Red Skull was promoted and operates as an independent counterpart of the SS.

His career is thug, SA, (fake bellboy), SS and Hitler's bodyguard, becomes Red Skull, independent counterpart of the SS.

ToS #66 p 8, shows war scenes so they are post 1 Sept 1939 (unless they are Spanish Civil War--from 1936 on--, Austria annexation--March 1938--or Czechoslovakia invasion--March 1939-- and killing dissidents to the annexations? Unlikely), so I put these after the newspaper page.

So his further chronology goes:
ToS #66 p 5 pn 6-7 - p 7 Hitler dissatisfied with Schmidt's training, turns him into Red Skull
Cover of Red Skull #4 Red Skull promoted and operates as an independent counterpart of the SS
ToS #66 p 8-9 Red Skull in wartime Europe

Translation of #4's cover:
http://theragingfanboy.wordpress.com/20 ... mber-2011/
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1443
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

Updated Red Skull chronology

Post by Leoparis »

I have Cap #298 now so I can update his early chronology.
Red Skull Incarnate: RSI

CA 298 (8 - 10:2)-FB (from birth to seven years old)
RSI 1 (1923 Johann is nine, leaves the Home for wayward boys)
TOS 66/2 (3:1 - 3:2)-FB (Johann steals chicken but gets beaten up and stolen in turn)
RSI 2 (Nov 1926, Johann steals apple but gets beaten up and stolen in turn, fights back with a knife
taken over by a Jewish shopkeeper and his daughter Emmy. Mar 1927 abandons the Jewish family)

CA 298 (10:5 - 10:6)-FB (hides in darkness)
TOS 66/2 (3:3 - 3:5)-FB (this last panel shows a tavern owner and a young woman)
CA 298 (11:4 - 11:7)-FB (kills a Jewish girl, Esther)
CA 298 (12:3 - 12:4)-FB (flees murder scene)
RSI 3 (Early 1933, Rise of nazi party to power, Johann joins the SA
RSI 4 (Late 1933, Johann reconnects with Dieter
Remove: TOS 66/2 4:3 doesn't actually happen anymore, it shows the bellboy looking at a nazi meeting - Johann as an SA looked at a nazi meeting in Nuremberg in Red Skull #3 but now he was never an actual bellboy, that was part of his plot to get recruited by Hitler. Since it's part of a narrative, it's easy to dismiss)
RSI 5 (1-13) June 29, 1934, Johann and Dieter go to Rohm's hotel
ToS 66 (4:5) Johann as bellboy (with Dieter in RSI 14:1) brings a platter
RSI 5 (14:2) They enter the room
ToS 66 (5:1) He puts the platter on the table (=RSI 5 14:3)
RSI 5 (14:4-18) Johann foils Dieter's assassination attempt
ToS 66 (5:3-5) Hitler decides to recruit Schmidt)
RSI 5 (19-20) Schmidt in SS uniform as bodyguard to Hitler in the wake of the Night of Long Knives)
[Z:BB 3] (Schmidt is Hitler's bodyguard)
[Z:BB 4] (idem)
ToS 66 (5:6-7 - 7) Hitler dissatisfied with Schmidt's training, turns him into Red Skull
RSI 4 cover (Newspaper dated March 16, 1939 tells us that Red Skull was promoted and operates as an independent counterpart of the SS.)
TOS 66/2 (8:2 - 9:1)-FB (Red Skull in wartime Europe)

I moved around the Zemo: Born Better issues to before Schmidt became the costumed Red Skull to better reflect how Hitler turned him from a nazi soldier to an agent of terror. While I'm not sure we can include a cover in a chronology, I put it there because of the important information it conveys.
Locked