BP 14-15

Discuss chronologies for characters in the main "Marvel Universe"

Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb

Post Reply
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1446
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

BP 14-15

Post by Leoparis »

Under Archie Goodwin's editorship (1976-78) writers were free to write their series with little regard to other series. When Jim Shooter took over he tightened continuity but this leads to difficulties because characters often came out from protracted storylines without breaks.

An example of this are the Kirby-led series. BP 1-13 occur in succession over two years in adventures abroad, yet Black Panther makes appearances in NYC, notably in Avengers (159 to 165 and then 172 to 180). BP 1-13 was placed between A 166 and 172. BP 14 is placed after A 181. Yet the start of BP 14 shows Wakanda appearing on the international scene in the last "couple of weeks" (in the wake of annexing Kiber's island in BP 13), Vision notices a change in T'Challa (as a result of BP 13), and T'Challa advises Captain America of the "recent Vibranium crisis" (in BP 7-10). Three references that make it implausible to stick 13 issues between BP 13 & 14.

The rest of the issue is contemporary with early 1979.

So my solution is to break BP 14 between 6:3 (when T'Challa reflects on his conversation with Cap) and 6:4 (start of the Klaw storyline in the present). Beast is not among those visiting at the embassy so the first section can take place after A 172 when Beast leaves for the X-Men mansion. Scarlet Witch is not in the second part so the fight with Klaw can take place after HSMASHA 2 (where she leaves for Transia) and thus be removed from Cap's quest for Falcon.

BP 7-13 Vibranium crisis, claims territory > A 172 Beast leaves, BP returns to the city, picks up Luke Charles' mail > M/TIO 40-41 in Luke Charles identity > BP 14 (1 - 6:3) opens embassy, mentions recent Vibranium crisis > A 173-174 kidnapped by Collector -> A 175-177 vs. Korvac >... > A 182 > CA 228-229 Cap searching for Falcon > HSMASHA 2 (Scarlet Witch leaves) > BP 14 (6:4 - 17)-15 > A 183 Ms. Marvel joins

Note: This will also solve other problems involving A 181, CA 228-229, HSMASHA 2.

Suggested corrections:
BEAST/HENRY "HANK" PHILIP MCCOY
A 182
*BP 14 move from here
*BP 15 move from here
CA 228
CA 229
HSMASHA 2
*BP 14 move here
*BP 15 move here
A 183

BLACK PANTHER VIII/T'CHALLA/"LUKE CHARLES"/"OKONKWO"
M/TIO 41
**BP 14 (1 - 6:3)
A 173
...
A 181
**BP 14 (6:4 -17)
BP 15

CAPTAIN AMERICA/STEVE ROGERS
A 172
**BP 14 (1 - 6:3) move here
A 173
...
A 182
*BP 14 move from here
*BP 15 move from here
CA 228
CA 229 (1 - 9:1)
HSMASHA 2
CA 229 (9:2 - 17)
CA 230 (1 - 14:3)
Q 2-FB
CA 230 (14:4 - 17)
IH2 232
IH2 233-BTS
CA 231 (1 - 11:5)
**BP 14 (6:4 -17) move here
**BP 15 move here
A 183

IRON MAN/ANTHONY EDWARD "TONY" STARK/"RICHARD FRANCO"
M/TU 70-BTS
**BP 14 (1 - 6:3) move here
A 173
...
A 182
**BP 14 move from here
CA 228
HSMASHA 2
**BP 14 (6:4 -17) move here
A 183

SCARLET WITCH II/WANDA MAXIMOFF
A 172
**BP 14 (1 - 6:3) move here
A 173
...
A 182
**BP 14 delete
CA 228

VISION II/"VICTOR SHADE"
A 172
**BP 14 (1 - 6:3) move here
A 173-BTS
...
A 182
**BP 14 move from here
**BP 15 move from here
CA 228
HSMASHA 2
**BP 14 (6:4 -17) move here
**BP 15 move here
A 183
Post Reply