Dr Strange in Uncanny X-Men 7 - 2013

Here's where you report issue analyses of any issue in any universe or timeline.

Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb

Post Reply
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1443
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

Dr Strange in Uncanny X-Men 7 - 2013

Post by Leoparis »

This is my attempt to pinpoint the flashback/time travel between Strange and Illyana. (Note: Wong's hands are seen serving tea.)
Leoparis wrote: In this issue we have a Dr Strange from the past. He doesn't know Illyana Rasputin. He knows Peter Rasputin, and knows the X-Men well. He met the new X-Men in X-Men Annual 4 (1980).

He's apparently free to teach though it is not necessary that we look at a time when he didn't already have a student.

He discovered Illyana's existence in UX 190-191, the Kulan Gath Saga (Feb-Mar 1985).

Clea is Strange's disciple until Dr Strange 55 (Oct 1982) so that leaves several years where to place his appearance.
Strange rejects the idea of training Illyana at the end of UX 191. It would make sense that he acted this way because he had been training the future Illyana and did not want to change history. He's also refusing disciples in DS2 57 and 58, which again makes sense if he has a time-traveling Illyana as a disciple by this time.

There is a gap between the time when Clea leaves Strange and the time when Illyana reappears from Limbo as a teen with her powers in X 160.
Spoiler:
Doctor Strange 49-55 Clea leaves
Daredevil 181
What If 35
Dazzler 15
Spider-Woman 42-44
Doctor Strange 56
Iron Man 157
Thor 318
Bizarre Adventures 32
Captain America 268
Defenders 106-109
Marvel Graphic Novel 1 (31 - 62) [The Death of Captain Marvel]
Silver Surfer Annual 6-FB
Fantastic Four Young Model Builders Club Giveaway 1
Fantastic Four Young Model Builders Club Giveaway 1/2
Fantastic Four Young Model Builders Club Giveaway
Fantastic Four 238/2
Fantastic Four 239
Fantastic Four 240
Peter Parker, the Spectacular Spider-Man 66
Amazing Spider-Man 228 (1-6)
Captain America 269
Ghost Rider 63-71
Defenders 110-111
Incredible Hulk 266-268
Marvel Fanfare 5
Marvel Fanfare 7
Giant-Size Incredible Hulk (2008) 1
Hulk Magazine 27/2
Amazing Spider-Man 228 (7 - 22)
Peter Parker, the Spectacular Spider-Man 67
Iron Man 158
Daredevil 182-185
Avengers 219-220
Fantastic Four 241
Amazing Spider-Man 229-230
Peter Parker, the Spectacular Spider-Man 68
Thor 319
Avengers Annual 11 vs Defenders
Rom 30 [Christmas Eve]
Marvel Fanfare 1/2 [Daredevil]
Fantastic Four 242-243
Fantastic Four 244 (4 - 16)
Rom 31-32
Silver Surfer III 14 (15:3)
Captain America 270
Marvel Fanfare 32/2
Fantastic Four 244 (1 - 3)
Fantastic Four 244 (17)-FB
Captain America 271
Questprobe 1
Uncanny X-Men 157-160 Illyana returns with powers
This is a good time period for her to travel to without crossing a past self that has the same powers of using Limbo. Since only the first meeting is shown but it is implied there will be more, she could have further meetings with Strange afterward until reaching X 160 or until her past self starts using her powers in NM 14 (Apr 84)/ MAGIK 1 (Dec 83).

Thzere is another related time travel in UX2 15.

My advice is to have UX3 7 after DS2 56 rather than before DS2 57 and I think it works best to extend the apprenticeship of Illyana. In UX3 15 the other students ask her "Where do you go when you're not here?" implying that she has made several back and forth time trips to apprentice under Strange since UX2 7, rather than have UX2 15 directly following from UX2 7 for Strange and Wong.

There are 8 issues between UX2 7 & 15 and ten Strange adventures between DS2 56 & 57 (DEF 106-109, M/GN 1 (37 - 62), DEF 110-117, M/S-HCOC 1-3, IH2 277-279, M/TIO 91, M/TU@ 5, M/TU 125/2, ROM 41-42, CRYS 3) so it's possible for Strange to have met Illyana a few times.

DOCTOR STRANGE/DR. STEPHEN VINCENT STRANGE
DS2 56
UX3 7
DEF 106
...
CRYS 3
UX3 15
DS2 57

MAGIK/ILLYANA RASPUTINA
UX3 6
UX3 7
UX3 8

WONG II
DS2 56
UX3 7
DEF 106
...
CRYS 3
UX3 15
DS2 57
Post Reply