Inter-company crossovers
Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb
-
- Major Player
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 7:37 pm
Inter-company crossovers
Cool! I'm glad to see the Amalgam stories added to the site. Just a quick note about some other items I've posted breakdowns for here:
Amazing High Adventure #1
Avengers Battle the Earth-Wrecker
Strange Combat Tales #1-4
all the Earth-7642 (Earth-Crossover) stories
Are these not going to be added? Still in the works but haven't been gotten to yet?
Edit: I also see that Access's chronology has been messed up. His appearances in DC vs Marvel have been replaced with his appearances in DC/Marvel: All Access, and his appearance in Doctor Strangefate #1 has been placed between #3 and #4 of All Access, rather than DC vs Marvel.
Edit 2: I also see that Spider-Man's appearance in SBOYTU #1 that I pointed out in my Amalgam thread wasn't added to his chronology. I realize that may be hard, but it's still an omission that I hope someone can fill.
Amazing High Adventure #1
Avengers Battle the Earth-Wrecker
Strange Combat Tales #1-4
all the Earth-7642 (Earth-Crossover) stories
Are these not going to be added? Still in the works but haven't been gotten to yet?
Edit: I also see that Access's chronology has been messed up. His appearances in DC vs Marvel have been replaced with his appearances in DC/Marvel: All Access, and his appearance in Doctor Strangefate #1 has been placed between #3 and #4 of All Access, rather than DC vs Marvel.
Edit 2: I also see that Spider-Man's appearance in SBOYTU #1 that I pointed out in my Amalgam thread wasn't added to his chronology. I realize that may be hard, but it's still an omission that I hope someone can fill.
Re: Update
7642 isn't. The policy on which universes to add (in the FAQ) was specifically written to exclude stories like those:vanhornluke wrote:Cool! I'm glad to see the Amalgam stories added to the site. Just a quick note about some other items I've posted breakdowns for here:
Amazing High Adventure #1
Avengers Battle the Earth-Wrecker
Strange Combat Tales #1-4
all the Earth-7642 (Earth-Crossover) stories
Are these not going to be added? Still in the works but haven't been gotten to yet?
Follow-Up Q. What about intercompany crossovers, like Marvel vs. DC, or Avengers/JLA?
When the Marvel Universe crosses over with another publisher's universe, it must be presented as two separate universes crossing, not existing in the same universe, to qualify for a listing (Avengers/JLA being a good example of this). In such a case, we'll list only the Marvel characters, as we're the MARVEL Chronology Project.
-
- Major Player
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 7:37 pm
Re: Update
That quote isn't relevant. It's addressing which intercompany crossovers are included as 616 stories. It's not saying that there can't be Earth-7642 listings in the alternate universe section. This should be obvious, since the Amalgam comics were just added, and they're intercompany crossovers on a shared Earth (i.e., "existing in the same universe"). If that quote ruled out adding 7642, it would rule out adding Amalgam as well.Somebody wrote:7642 isn't. The policy on which universes to add (in the FAQ) was specifically written to exclude stories like those:vanhornluke wrote:Cool! I'm glad to see the Amalgam stories added to the site. Just a quick note about some other items I've posted breakdowns for here:
Amazing High Adventure #1
Avengers Battle the Earth-Wrecker
Strange Combat Tales #1-4
all the Earth-7642 (Earth-Crossover) stories
Are these not going to be added? Still in the works but haven't been gotten to yet?Follow-Up Q. What about intercompany crossovers, like Marvel vs. DC, or Avengers/JLA?
When the Marvel Universe crosses over with another publisher's universe, it must be presented as two separate universes crossing, not existing in the same universe, to qualify for a listing (Avengers/JLA being a good example of this). In such a case, we'll list only the Marvel characters, as we're the MARVEL Chronology Project.
- Col_Fury
- Site Admin
- Posts: 7769
- Joined: Sun Jun 26, 2005 3:37 am
- Location: on a Helicarrier, above Illinois
- Contact:
Re: Update
Does this look right for Access?
ACCESS/AXEL ASHER
*DCV.M/ 1
*DCV.M/ 2
*DCV.M/ 3
**DSFATE (move to here)
*DCV.M/ 4
*DC/M/:AACC 1-FB
DC/M/:AACC 1
DC/M/:AACC 2
DC/M/:AACC 3
**DSFATE (move from here)
DC/M/:AACC 4
*UACC 1
*UACC 2
*UACC 3
*UACC 4
ACCESS/AXEL ASHER
*DCV.M/ 1
*DCV.M/ 2
*DCV.M/ 3
**DSFATE (move to here)
*DCV.M/ 4
*DC/M/:AACC 1-FB
DC/M/:AACC 1
DC/M/:AACC 2
DC/M/:AACC 3
**DSFATE (move from here)
DC/M/:AACC 4
*UACC 1
*UACC 2
*UACC 3
*UACC 4
-Daron Jensen
Re: Update
Well, considering that I was one of the guys who wrote it (along with Fury & Kevin W)....vanhornluke wrote:That quote isn't relevant. It's addressing which intercompany crossovers are included as 616 stories.
No, the Amalgam stuff exists as part of DC vs. Marvel. Which was an inter-universe crossover. They exist in the same universe in a similar way to Avengers/JLA #3-4 - a universe which is merged (and unmerged, then recreated) in story. As opposed to a story which just starts with Spider-Man & Batman in the same universe without explanation.vanhornluke wrote:It's not saying that there can't be Earth-7642 listings in the alternate universe section. This should be obvious, since the Amalgam comics were just added, and they're intercompany crossovers on a shared Earth (i.e., "existing in the same universe"). If that quote ruled out adding 7642, it would rule out adding Amalgam as well.
-
- Major Player
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 7:37 pm
Re: Update
Yes. He actually has another appearance during Unlimited Access in an issue of Green Lantern (he shows up looking for Kyle because of events in UACC 1), but I figured you'd probably opt to leave it out, since that one wasn't published by Marvel.Col_Fury wrote:Does this look right for Access?
ACCESS/AXEL ASHER
*DCV.M/ 1
*DCV.M/ 2
*DCV.M/ 3
**DSFATE (move to here)
*DCV.M/ 4
*DC/M/:AACC 1-FB
DC/M/:AACC 1
DC/M/:AACC 2
DC/M/:AACC 3
**DSFATE (move from here)
DC/M/:AACC 4
*UACC 1
*UACC 2
*UACC 3
*UACC 4
-
- Major Player
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 7:37 pm
Re: Update
Oh, I'm sorry, I didn't know you'd helped write that quote. If that's really what you meant by it, I have to say that quote is unclear, since it sure seems like it's saying that shared Earth crossovers aren't considered 616, not that non-616 shared Earth stories can't be listed among the alternate universes. I don't see what the problem is with the shared Earth being unexplained, since 7642 is listed as an alternate universe in the handbooks and we actually see brief glimpses of it in an issue of What If and an issue of Avengers Forever. There's no explanation for the existence of the various DC analogues in Not Brand Echh or What The, but that wasn't considered a reason to bar listing those alternate universes.Somebody wrote:Well, considering that I was one of the guys who wrote it (along with Fury & Kevin W)....vanhornluke wrote:That quote isn't relevant. It's addressing which intercompany crossovers are included as 616 stories.
No, the Amalgam stuff exists as part of DC vs. Marvel. Which was an inter-universe crossover. They exist in the same universe in a similar way to Avengers/JLA #3-4 - a universe which is merged (and unmerged, then recreated) in story. As opposed to a story which just starts with Spider-Man & Batman in the same universe without explanation.vanhornluke wrote:It's not saying that there can't be Earth-7642 listings in the alternate universe section. This should be obvious, since the Amalgam comics were just added, and they're intercompany crossovers on a shared Earth (i.e., "existing in the same universe"). If that quote ruled out adding 7642, it would rule out adding Amalgam as well.
- Col_Fury
- Site Admin
- Posts: 7769
- Joined: Sun Jun 26, 2005 3:37 am
- Location: on a Helicarrier, above Illinois
- Contact:
Re: Update
What issue of Green Lantern?vanhornluke wrote:Yes. He actually has another appearance during Unlimited Access in an issue of Green Lantern (he shows up looking for Kyle because of events in UACC 1), but I figured you'd probably opt to leave it out, since that one wasn't published by Marvel.
-Daron Jensen
-
- Chronology Guru
- Posts: 9935
- Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2004 6:24 pm
- Location: Milton, Florida
Re: Update
Green Lantern #87 (Jun 1997)
Access is jointly owned by both Marvel and DC and his DC appearance should be noted in his chronology.
Also if Marvel gives another company permission to use their character (for an upcoming cross-over) that the story meets the qualification for inclusion in the MCP, shouldn't we track the Marvel Characters appearance. (It's been a long time, but I believe Mojo appeared in Youngblood and Mephisto appeared in Witchblade.
Access is jointly owned by both Marvel and DC and his DC appearance should be noted in his chronology.
Also if Marvel gives another company permission to use their character (for an upcoming cross-over) that the story meets the qualification for inclusion in the MCP, shouldn't we track the Marvel Characters appearance. (It's been a long time, but I believe Mojo appeared in Youngblood and Mephisto appeared in Witchblade.
- Col_Fury
- Site Admin
- Posts: 7769
- Joined: Sun Jun 26, 2005 3:37 am
- Location: on a Helicarrier, above Illinois
- Contact:
Re: Update
Thanks!
Looking at it online, it even says on the cover that he appears. Neat!
Looking at it online, it even says on the cover that he appears. Neat!
-Daron Jensen
- Russ Chappell
- Site Admin
- Posts: 5678
- Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2004 5:40 pm
- Location: Tuscaloosa, AL
- Contact:
Re: Update
If it's an inter-universe crossover, then yes.Jason Doty wrote:if Marvel gives another company permission to use their character (for an upcoming cross-over) that the story meets the qualification for inclusion in the MCP, shouldn't we track the Marvel Characters appearance. (It's been a long time, but I believe Mojo appeared in Youngblood and Mephisto appeared in Witchblade.
(Are you sure it was Mojo? We're already tracking both Domos in YOUNGBLOOD vol 2 #10. Are you sure it was "Witchblade"? We're already tracking Mephisto in both Witchblade/Elektra and Wolverine/Witchblade.)
I can't promise you that things will improve, if we make changes;
I can promise you that they won't improve, if we don't.
Adventures in the Marvelous Zone! A Girl's View of the Marvel Universe
I can promise you that they won't improve, if we don't.
Adventures in the Marvelous Zone! A Girl's View of the Marvel Universe
-
- Major Player
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 7:37 pm
Re: Update
Yes, Mephisto briefly appears in Witchblade #11 as a lead-in to the "Devil's Reign" event.Russ Chappell wrote:Are you sure it was "Witchblade"? We're already tracking Mephisto in both Witchblade/Elektra and Wolverine/Witchblade.)
-
- Major Player
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 7:37 pm
Re: Inter-company crossovers
Ironically, while I unintentionally started a discussion of some intercompany crossovers, my original question was never actually answered. What about the other stories I posted chronological breakdowns for? Will they be added to the site?
- Russ Chappell
- Site Admin
- Posts: 5678
- Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2004 5:40 pm
- Location: Tuscaloosa, AL
- Contact:
Re: Inter-company crossovers
There are no plans to add text pieces to the Project.
The Handbooks may say that the events in a particular story happened, and that's fine, but we don't plan to add text stories, or any other form of media, to the Project. We'll add comic stories in comic books, graphic novels and comic magazines (such as Dracula Lives, or Monsters Unleashed). If the Handbook says that events shown in a Broadway play, a Paul McCartney song, an ad for jelly doughnuts, or a roll of Hulk toilet tissue actually happened, more power to them, but we're not adding them here.
The other comic books that you mentioned probably will be added eventually, although not to the extent they were analyzed here. The analysis posted here includes chronologies for people whom we only have a first name, and those don't qualify for listings; but where appropriate, we'll add them.
The Handbooks may say that the events in a particular story happened, and that's fine, but we don't plan to add text stories, or any other form of media, to the Project. We'll add comic stories in comic books, graphic novels and comic magazines (such as Dracula Lives, or Monsters Unleashed). If the Handbook says that events shown in a Broadway play, a Paul McCartney song, an ad for jelly doughnuts, or a roll of Hulk toilet tissue actually happened, more power to them, but we're not adding them here.
The other comic books that you mentioned probably will be added eventually, although not to the extent they were analyzed here. The analysis posted here includes chronologies for people whom we only have a first name, and those don't qualify for listings; but where appropriate, we'll add them.
I can't promise you that things will improve, if we make changes;
I can promise you that they won't improve, if we don't.
Adventures in the Marvelous Zone! A Girl's View of the Marvel Universe
I can promise you that they won't improve, if we don't.
Adventures in the Marvelous Zone! A Girl's View of the Marvel Universe
-
- Major Player
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 7:37 pm
Re: Inter-company crossovers
So I shouldn't bother posting any breakdowns for Martin Goodman's magazines, even though they contain 616 stories?