miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Discuss chronologies for characters in the main "Marvel Universe"

Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb

User avatar
michel
Director
Director
Posts: 3148
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: France
Contact:

miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by michel »

1) Doom and Nova make each a one-panel cameo in T 271, while Thor and Iron Man fight the FAUST Satellite. The Thing makes a three-panel cameo in NO 13, startled by Nova flying in front of his window while he reads Dracula. I don't see how T 271 could be split in two.

For Doom, T 271 is before FF 195-196 :

DOCTOR DOOM/VICTOR VON DOOM
MOKF 60
T 271
FF 192-BTS
FF 193-BTS
FF 195-BTS
FF 196

FF 197
FF 198
FF 199
FF 200

For the Thing, NO 13 is in between FF 195 and 196 :

THING/BENJAMIN J. GRIMM
FF 194
FF 195
NO 13
FF 196

FF 197

And for Nova, T 271 is after NO 13 :

NOVA/RICHARD RIDER
NO 12
ASM 171
NO 13
NO 14
NO 15
NO 16
NO 17
NO 18
NO 18/2
T 271
DEF 62

Either we move T 271 in between FF 195 and 196 for Doom, or T 271 before NO 13 for Nova. In the "Placement of Thor 269-271" thread, Paul stated that T 271 had to happen after FF 191, and Colonel Fury had it before FF 192. But can't it be placed in between FF 195 and 196, still before Doom is imprisoned in FF 200 ?


2) Jarvis appears in UX@ 3, not X@ 3

JARVIS, EDWIN
A 180-BTS
* UX@3 was X@ 3
FF 204

3) I find MSM 19 and 22 misplaced for Jonah Jameson.

For Jonah, MSM 19 is after PPTSS 21. Jonah meets Peter Parker in PPTSS 21. For Spider-Man, PPTSS 21 is after M/TU 71. Spider-Man meets Captain America in M/TU 71. For Captain America, M/TU 71 is after A 170-177. Captain America meets Ms. Marvel in A 175. And for Ms. Marvel, A 175 is after MSM 19.

Jonah is BTS in MSM 22 because Carol finds on her desk a letter from him telling her she's fired as editor of the Woman Magazine. This letter had to be written in between MSM 19 and 22.

For Jonah, MSM is after GZILL 23. Jonah faces Godzilla in GZILL 23 just before the Avengers and Captain America are warned. For Captain America, GZILL 23 is after A@ 8. Captain America meets Ms. Marvel in A@ 8. And for Ms. Marvel, A@ 8 is after MSM 22.

Are we okay with that before I try to replace MSM 19 and 22 for Jonah ?

4) In S-W 4, Bill Foster picks up Jerry Hunt at LA Airport, as his boss Tony Stark asked him to. For Bill, it's after DEF 65 :

BLACK GOLIATH/DR. WILLIAM "BILL" BARRETT FOSTER
CHAMP 15-BTS
DEF 62
DEF 63
DEF 64
DEF 65
S-W 4

M/TIO 54

But for Tony Stark, it's before DEF 63

IRON MAN/ANTHONY EDWARD "TONY" STARK
A@ 8
S-W 4-BTS
DEF 63

FF 202

I'm not sure this is wrong, Stark could have asked Bill to pick Jerry up before DEF 62-65. What do you think ?

5) Ginger Jaye appears in M/TIO@ 3, not M/TIO@ 2

JAYE-FIRESTONE, GINGER
NO 18
NO 18/2
* M/TIO@3 was M/TIO@ 2
NO 19

6) The first chronological appearance for Bethany Cabe is when she was married to Alexander Van Tilberg, in IM 128-FB, not IM 128

CABE, BETHANY
* IM 128-FB FB added
{IM 117}
IM 118
Michael
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1352
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 10:41 am

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by Michael »

michel wrote:
3) I find MSM 19 and 22 misplaced for Jonah Jameson.

For Jonah, MSM 19 is after PPTSS 21. Jonah meets Peter Parker in PPTSS 21. For Spider-Man, PPTSS 21 is after M/TU 71. Spider-Man meets Captain America in M/TU 71. For Captain America, M/TU 71 is after A 170-177. Captain America meets Ms. Marvel in A 175. And for Ms. Marvel, A 175 is after MSM 19.

Jonah is BTS in MSM 22 because Carol finds on her desk a letter from him telling her she's fired as editor of the Woman Magazine. This letter had to be written in between MSM 19 and 22.

For Jonah, MSM is after GZILL 23. Jonah faces Godzilla in GZILL 23 just before the Avengers and Captain America are warned. For Captain America, GZILL 23 is after A@ 8. Captain America meets Ms. Marvel in A@ 8. And for Ms. Marvel, A@ 8 is after MSM 22.

Are we okay with that before I try to replace MSM 19 and 22 for Jonah ?
I discussed the problem with the placement of MSM 22 in this thread:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=5159
Basically it's the result of a contradiction between Ward's Index and Olshevsky's Index.
User avatar
michel
Director
Director
Posts: 3148
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: France
Contact:

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by michel »

Michael wrote:So should MSM 22 be moved after A 181 or should Jonah's firing Carol be moved to before ASM 190?
It's Jonah's MSM 22-BTS that seems out of place, the Avengers' and Spider-Man's timelines don't cross much in much period, it's not that easy to place MSM 19 and 22 in Jonah's chronology.

For Ms. Marvel, MSM 19 is in between A 172 and 175. For Beast, M/TU 69 is in between pages A 172. For Captain America, M/TU 71 is after A 177. That puts MSM 19 roughly in between M/TU 69 and 71.

For Ms. Marvel, MSM 22 is in between A 177 and A@ 8. For Captain America, A@ 8 is a little after M/TU 71. MSM 19 still could be before M/TU 71.

JAMESON, J. JONAH JR.
MSM 9
ASM@ 11
ASM 172
ASM 174
ASM 175
ASM 176
ASM 178
ASM 179-BTS
ASM 180
* M/TIO 40
PPTSS 16

SPIDER-MAN/PETER BENJAMIN PARKER
A 168
M/TU 69
M/TU 70
ASM@ 11
ASM@ 11/2
COH 2
WI? 7
ASM 172
ASM 173
ASM 174
ASM 175
ASM 176
ASM 177
ASM 178
ASM 179
ASM 180
T 271
PPTSS 12
PPTSS 13
PPTSS 14
PPTSS 15
M/TU 71
PPTSS 16

For Jonah, MSM 19 and 22 could be placed in between MSM 9 and PPTSS 16. In the "Some Spider-Man placements from 1979" thread, I already have proposed to put M/TIO 40 in between ASM 180 and PPTSS 16 for Jonah. Couldn't we place MSM 19 and MSM 22-BTS here too ?
User avatar
michel
Director
Director
Posts: 3148
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: France
Contact:

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by michel »

7) Mr. Fantastic is listed BTS in M/TIO 63 in between M/TIO 60 and UX 135, when for the Thing M/TIO 63 is after UX 135. I've checked M/TIO 63 but can't see where Mr. Fantastic is mentioned. What do I miss ?

8) Franklin Richards appears with the Fantastic Four in FF@ 14. But for him, it's after FF 215-216, while for the FF it's before. In FF@ 14, the Thing mentions the FF fought Blastaar, and that was in FF 215-216. So it looks like FF@ 14 must be moved for the FF, and for the Avengers and Spider-Man too. Thoughts ?
Michael
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1352
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 10:41 am

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by Michael »

We discussed M/TIO 61-63 in this thread a few months ago:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=5051
In any case, Ward's Avengers Index 4 placed FF 215 after FF@ 14.
User avatar
michel
Director
Director
Posts: 3148
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: France
Contact:

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by michel »

Michael wrote:We discussed M/TIO 61-63 in this thread a few months ago:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=5051
In your last post in this thread, you have M/TIO 63-BTS after UX 135 for Reed, so it's just not been changed in the MCP yet ?

Michael wrote:In any case, Ward's Avengers Index 4 placed FF 215 after FF@ 14.
In the book itself, the Thing says FF@ 14 is after FF 215-216. Doesn't that takes precedence over the index ?
Michael
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1352
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 10:41 am

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by Michael »

michel wrote:
Michael wrote:We discussed M/TIO 61-63 in this thread a few months ago:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=5051
In your last post in this thread, you have M/TIO 63-BTS after UX 135 for Reed, so it's just not been changed in the MCP yet ?
We were trying to figure this out for the X-Men Index TPB. I don't have the TPB in front of me-Jeph can tell you the final result.

michel wrote:
Michael wrote:In any case, Ward's Avengers Index 4 placed FF 215 after FF@ 14.
In the book itself, the Thing says FF@ 14 is after FF 215-216. Doesn't that takes precedence over the index ?
Ordinarily, yes. But sometimes the Indexes disregarded references for a reason. This whole period of time is very complicated:
Olshevsky placed the Dark Phoenix Saga a year out of sync with the Avengers.
DEF 76-77 take place immediately before A 189. In A 189, Hank gets a call from Jan to come pick her up. He does that in DEF 78, and in that issue, Moondragon leaves to have her adventure in M/TIO 61-63.
Ward's Index placed FF@ 14 in between A 185 and A 186. It placed FF 215 and 216 in between pages of A 189. Come to think of it, maybe FF 215-216 can be moved immediately before FF@ 14.
ETA: There's one further complication- Strange's and Clea's chronologies in this period need to be corrected, as this thread shows:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=5110
And we never settled the question of where to place FF@ 14 in the Defenders' chronology:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=5156
Just to make it clear why this is important- currently Strange's appearance in UX 135 is placed between pages 7 and 8 of DRSTR2 42. And UX 135 is placed between A 185 and A 186.
User avatar
michel
Director
Director
Posts: 3148
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: France
Contact:

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by michel »

Okay, it's too late for me to study that now, I'll give it a look tomorrow. But meanwhile, I spotted something else.

9) A 77 is a bit complicated.
In the frame story, the Avengers (Black Panther, Goliath, Quicksilver, Scarlet Witch, Vision) work for Cornelius van Lunt and fight Kronus and his Split-Second Squad.
In a prior FB, Tony Stark visits the aforementioned Avengers, asks them the rent for Avengers Mansion, and the Avengers decide to work for van Lunt.
In three FB-FB, Black Panther, Goliath, then Quicksilver and Vision fight vs. the Split-Second Squad

For Quicksilver and Vision, it's OK, we have :
A 76
H2 128
A 77-FB-FB
A 77-FB
A 77
A 78

Black Panther has A 77 and the -FB-FB, but not the pFB :
A 74
A 77-FB-FB
DD 69 (8:2)-FB
CA 121
A 75
A 76
H2 128
* A 77-FB added
A 77
DD 69 (8:3 - 11:1)-FB
A 77
DD 69 (11:4 - 12:1)-FB
A 78

Scarlet Witch misses the pFB too :
A 76
H2 128
* A 77-FB added
A 77
A 78

and Goliath/Hawkeye has the -FB instead of the -FB-FB, and misses the pFB :
A 68
* A 77-FB-FB was A 77-FB
IM 18
A 69
A 70
A 71
A 72
A 73
A 74
A 75
A 76
H2 128
* A 77-FB added
A 77
A 78
Michael
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1352
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 10:41 am

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by Michael »

michel wrote:
Michael wrote:So should MSM 22 be moved after A 181 or should Jonah's firing Carol be moved to before ASM 190?
For Jonah, MSM 19 and 22 could be placed in between MSM 9 and PPTSS 16. In the "Some Spider-Man placements from 1979" thread, I already have proposed to put M/TIO 40 in between ASM 180 and PPTSS 16 for Jonah. Couldn't we place MSM 19 and MSM 22-BTS here too ?
MSM 19 could go there but MSM 22-BTS can't. Carol is still working for Woman magazine in M/TU 76. So MSM 22 has to take place after M/TU 76 and Carol's chronology needs to be changed. This problem was the result of contradictions between Olshevsky's index and Ward's Index. Olshevsky's Marvel Team-Up Index 4 placed M/TU 76-77 in between DEF 63 and A 183. Ward's Avengers index 4 confused the matter by not mentioning M/TU 76-77 in Carol's chronology (although M/TU 77 is listed as taking place after A@ 8 in Strange's and Clea's chronologies), and by confusing the issue of Carol's appearances in between A 177 and A@ 8. The entry for A 177 lists Carol as appearing in MSM 20-21 in between A 177 and A@ 8, but the entry for A@ 8 lists Carol's last appearance before A@ 8 as MSM 22. *brickwall*
User avatar
michel
Director
Director
Posts: 3148
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: France
Contact:

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by michel »

Good catch, Michael ! M/TU 76 is very interesting indeed : Ms. Marvel appears in her new costume in front of Spider-Man. Spidey met her in M/TU 61-62, but asks how can he be sure it's her in this new costume ? She answers he shouldn't check with the Avengers, they haven't seen this outfit outside of the Wasp. Carol says in MSM 20, the first appearance of the new costume, she had a little design assistance from Janet Pym : the Wasp should get a MSM 20-BTS appearance. But above all, Ms. Marvel meets the whole Avengers team in A@ 8, so M/TU 76-77 is before A@ 8. It's not MSM 22 that must be put after M/TU 76-77, it's M/TU 76-77 that must be moved in between MSM 20 and 22, and before A@ 8.

There's a gap in MSM 20 between pages 3 and 4. In (1-3), Carol admires her new costume and learns about Sharon Cole's disappearance, the day is Saturday. On page 4, it's Tuesday morning, Carol is in New Mexico, the text says : "Carol had been in an important meeting with Jonah Jameson when the call came in about Sharon. Within an hour, she was aboard a flight out of Kennedy Airport. Jameson had been in a fine fury at her sudden exit, but Carol couldn't care less". Jonah misses a MSM 20-BTS in his listing. Ms. Marvel confronts the Lizard People in MSM 20-21, it's when she comes back at work at the beginning of MSM 22 that she learns she's fired.

So Ms. Marvel's chronology could look like :

A 177
KS
MSM 20 (1-3) (new costume)
M/TU 76 (still working for Woman magazine, Avengers haven't seen the new costume yet)
M/TU 77
MSM 20 (4-17)
MSM 21
MSM 22 (fired from Woman Magazine)
A@ 8 (meets the Avengers)
DEF 62
DEF 63
CA 237

Moving M/TU 76-77 implies changes for Spider-Man. Some M/TU issues in this period are out of order, can't it be the same for M/TU 76-77 ?
Michael
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1352
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 10:41 am

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by Michael »

Keep in mind that Strange, Clea and Wong appear in A@ 8 as well. Their chronologies need to be changed.
Is there any reason why we can't just move M/TU 76-77 before A@ 8 without affecting the rest of Peter's chronology?
User avatar
michel
Director
Director
Posts: 3148
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: France
Contact:

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by michel »

Michael wrote:This whole period of time is very complicated:
Olshevsky placed the Dark Phoenix Saga a year out of sync with the Avengers.
DEF 76-77 take place immediately before A 189. In A 189, Hank gets a call from Jan to come pick her up. He does that in DEF 78, and in that issue, Moondragon leaves to have her adventure in M/TIO 61-63.
Ward's Index placed FF@ 14 in between A 185 and A 186. It placed FF 215 and 216 in between pages of A 189. Come to think of it, maybe FF 215-216 can be moved immediately before FF@ 14.
Moving FF 215-216 just before FF@ 14 disrupts FF 215 happening during A 189. You're right about Dr. Strange, there's no gap in between DRSTR2 42 and 43. Michael, what do you think about this timeline :

DEF 68
A 178-180
DRSTR2 35-37 (Cap and Iron Man just after A 180)
UX 125-128 (Proteus story)
A 181 part 1
FF 204 (Torch meets Jarvis during A 181, tries to see Spider-Man during ASM 190)
A 181 part 2
ASM 190 part 2, 191-193 (ASM 193 before FF 207 for Spider-Man)
A 182-185
FF 205-214
M/TIO 51-59
IM 123 part 1
FF 215-216
FF@ 14 (Thing refers to Blastaar from FF 215-216 ; Iron Man in between pages IM 123)
M/TIO 60
IM 123 part 2, 124-126
DRSTR2 38-40 (DRSTR2 38 three days after DRSTR2 37)
M-T2 4
DRSTR2 41, 42 (1-8)
UX 129-137
DRSTR2 42 (9-17), 43-44
UX 138
A 186-188
A@ 9
DEF 69-77
A 189 part 1
DEF 78-84
M/TIO 61-63
A 189 part 2

UX 129-137 and DRSTR2 38-44 happen roughly at the same time
Michael
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1352
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 10:41 am

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by Michael »

That might work. Is there any reason why FF 215 has to take place between pages of A 189?
I found the following post in Archive 47:
Thread 31

Posted: 20 May 2004 03:49 am Post subject: Doctor Strange and supporting cast
By Peter Fabricius

I have tested the program I mentioned in another thread, and found the following interesting things comparing Doctor strange with some of his supporting cast.

SARA WOLFE
...
DRSTR2 63
*DRSTR3 65 (should be DRSTR2 65)
DRSTR2 66
...

I am fairly certain this is a typo, she is definetely not in DRSTR3 65.
I don't have DRSTR2 65, but I presume she is in that one.

---
DR. STRANGE II/STEPHEN STRANGE
...
DEF 71
DEF 72
DEF 73
DEF 74
DEF 75
DEF 78
DEF 79
DEF 80
DEF 81
DEF 82
DEF 83
DEF 84
DRSTR2 43
DRSTR2 44
...

WONG
...
DRSTR2 43
DRSTR2 44
*DEF 71
*DEF 78
*DEF 80-BTS
...

I have neither the Doctor Strange issues, nor the Defenders issues, but unless one of them was engaged in timetravel, there is something wrong here.
Presumably Stranges appearances are correct, so the 3 Defendes issues should be moved up before DRSTR2 43 on Wong's listing.

---

CLEA
...
DRSTR2 42
DRSTR2 43
DRSTR2 44
*DEF 70
*DEF 71
*DEF 72
*DEF 73
*DEF 74
*DEF 75
*DEF 78
*DEF 80
*DEF 84
...

DR. STRANGE II/STEPHEN STRANGE
...
DRSTR2 42
DEF 69
DEF 70
DEF 71
DEF 72
DEF 73
DEF 74
DEF 75
DEF 78
DEF 79
DEF 80
DEF 81
DEF 82
DEF 83
DEF 84
DRSTR2 43
DRSTR2 44

Basically the same issues here, again I suggest moving DEF 70-84 up between DRSTR2 42 and 43 as in Strange's listing.
So DEF 70-84 WERE originally placed after DRSTR2 44 in Clea's and Wong's chronologies, just like you've placed them.
The reason why FF@ 14 should ideally be placed before DEF 76 has to do with Kyle's chronology. In DEF 76, Kyle receives a court order forbidding him to act as Nighthawk. He violates it in DEF 80-81 when he finds out that Patsy and Val are being controlled by the Mandrill, is arrested and then doesn't become Nighthawk again until DEF 88. Since Kyle appears in costume in FF@ 14, moving FF@ 14 might cause problems. Your solution avoids those problems.
While we're on the subject of FF 215-216, shouldn't Doctor Sun be placed behind-the-scenes in FF 215-216? He's manipulating HERBIE during this period, and it's fairly obvious that he's the one who let Blastaar in.
Truthfully, when you brought this subject up, I was disappointed. We went over this period last summer, when we were helping Jeph prepare the X-Men Index TPB, and I was disappointed that the reference to Blastaar in FF@ 14 wasn't spotted. :oops: But you seem to have come up with a solution that fits all the issues.
So Reed's and Ben's revised chronolgies should be:
MR. FANTASTIC/REED RICHARDS
...
M/TIO 52-BTS
FF 215
FF 216
FF@ 14
M/TIO 60
UX 135
M/TIO 63-BTS
M/TIO 64
...

THING/BENJAMIN J. GRIMM
...
M/TIO 59
FF 215
FF 216
FF@ 14
M/TIO 60
UX 135
M/TIO 61
M/TIO 62
M/TIO 63
M/TIO 64
...
User avatar
michel
Director
Director
Posts: 3148
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: France
Contact:

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by michel »

michel wrote:1) Either we move T 271 in between FF 195 and 196 for Doom, or T 271 before NO 13 for Nova. In the "Placement of Thor 269-271" thread, Paul stated that T 271 had to happen after FF 191, and Colonel Fury had it before FF 192. But can't it be placed in between FF 195 and 196, still before Doom is imprisoned in FF 200 ?
If this hypothesis is confirmed, proposed chronology :

DOCTOR DOOM/VICTOR VON DOOM
MOKF 60
* T 271 moved from here
FF 192-BTS
FF 193-BTS
FF 195-BTS
* T 271 moved here
FF 196
FF 197
FF 198
FF 199
FF 200

michel wrote:3) So Ms. Marvel's chronology could look like :

A 177
KS
MSM 20 (1-3) (new costume)
M/TU 76 (still working for Woman magazine, Avengers haven't seen the new costume yet)
M/TU 77
MSM 20 (4-17)
MSM 21
MSM 22 (fired from Woman Magazine)
A@ 8 (meets the Avengers)
DEF 62
DEF 63
CA 237
If this hypothesis is confirmed, proposed chronologies :

MS. MARVEL/CAROL SUSAN JANE DANVERS
KS
* MSM 20 (1-3) splitted in two
* M/TU 76 moved here
* M/TU 77 moved here
* MSM 20 (4-17) splitted in two

MSM 21
MSM 22
A@ 8
DEF 62
DEF 63
* M/TU 76 moved from here
* M/TU 77 moved from here

CA 237

JAMESON, J. JONAH JR.
ASM 180
* M/TIO 40
** MSM 19 moved here
** MSM 20-BTS added
** MSM 22-BTS moved here

PPTSS 16
PPTSS 19
* DEF 61
ASM 182
ASM 190-FB
ASM 184
PPTSS 21
** MSM 19 moved from here
ASM 185/2
ASM 186
GZILL 23-24
ASM 187-188
PPTSS 28
ASM 189-192
ASM 201-FB
ASM 192-196
** MSM 22-BTS moved from here
ASM 197

WASP/JANET VAN DYNE PYM
A 176
A 177
KS
* MSM 20-BTS added
A@ 8

CLEA | DOCTOR STRANGE II/DR. STEPHEN VINCENT STRANGE/"STEPHEN SANDERS" | WONG
DRSTR2 33
* M/TU 76 moved here
* M/TU 77 moved here

A@ 8
* M/TU 76 moved from here
* M/TU 77 moved from here

M/TU 80
M/TU 81
DRSTR2 34

SPIDER-MAN/PETER BENJAMIN PARKER
ASM 180
* M/TU 76 moved here
* M/TU 77 moved here

T 271
PPTSS 12-15
M/TU 71
PPTSS 16-20
DEF 61
ASM 182-185
PPTSS 21
M/TU 72
DD2 69-FB
PPTSS 22-23
ASM 185/2
ASM 186
M/TU 73
PPTSS 24
M/TU 74
M/TU 75
* M/TU 76 moved from here
* M/TU 77 moved from here

M/TU 78

WATSON-PARKER, MARY JANE
ASM 179
* M/TU 76 moved here
ASM 182
ASM 183
PPTSS 21
PPTSS 23
PPTSS 24
M/TU 74
M/TU 75
* M/TU 76 moved from here
ASM 188

michel wrote:7) Mr. Fantastic is listed BTS in M/TIO 63 in between M/TIO 60 and UX 135, when for the Thing M/TIO 63 is after UX 135. I've checked M/TIO 63 but can't see where Mr. Fantastic is mentioned. What do I miss ?

8) Franklin Richards appears with the Fantastic Four in FF@ 14. But for him, it's after FF 215-216, while for the FF it's before. In FF@ 14, the Thing mentions the FF fought Blastaar, and that was in FF 215-216. So it looks like FF@ 14 must be moved for the FF, and for the Avengers and Spider-Man too. Thoughts ?
In the hypothesis FF 215-216 is moved before FF@ 14, proposed chronologies :

CAPTAIN AMERICA/STEVEN "GRANT" ROGERS
CA 240
* FF 215 moved here
FF@ 14
IM 125 (1 - 8:2)
IM/CA:COW (32:3 - 33:1)-FB
IM/CA:COW (33:3)-FB
IM/CA:COW (34:1)-FB
IM 125 (8:3 - 8:10)
IM/CA:COW (35:1)-FB
IM/CA:COW (35:3)-FB
IM/CA:COW (37)-FB
A 186
A 187
A 188
CA 241
CA 242
M/PRM 49
A@ 9
A 189
* FF 215 moved from here
* A 189 deleted

CA 243

HUMAN TORCH II/JOHNNY STORM
M/TIO 59
* FF 215 moved here
* FF 216 moved here

FF@ 14
* FF 215 moved from here
* FF 216 moved from here

M/TIO 68

INVISIBLE WOMAN/SUE STORM RICHARDS
FF 214
* FF 215 moved here
* FF 216 moved here

FF@ 14
* FF 215 moved from here
* FF 216 moved from here

M/TIO 69

MR. FANTASTIC/REED RICHARDS
M/TIO 52-BTS
* FF 215 moved here
* FF 216 moved here

FF@ 14
M/TIO 60
* M/TIO 63-BTS moved from here
UX 135
* FF 215 moved from here
* FF 216 moved from here

* M/TIO 63-BTS moved here but where is the Reed's reference ?
M/TIO 64

THING/BENJAMIN J. GRIMM
M/TIO 59
* FF 215 moved here
* FF 216 moved here

FF@ 14
M/TIO 60
UX 135
M/TIO 61
M/TIO 62 (1 - 16)
H2 266 (10:1)-FB
M/TIO 62 (17)
M/TIO 63
* FF 215 moved from here
* FF 216 moved from here

M/TIO 64

VISION II
A 185
* FF 215 moved here
FF@ 14
IM 125
A 186
A 188
IM 127-BTS
A@ 9
A 189
* FF 215 moved from here
* A 189 deleted

A 190


Reassembling DRSTR2 42 and DRSTR2 43-44 implies :

CLEA
DRSTR2 40
DRSTR2 42
* DRSTR2 43 moved here
* DRSTR2 44 moved here

DEF 70
DEF 71
DEF 72
DEF 73
DEF 74
DEF 75
DEF 78
DEF 80
DEF 84
* DRSTR2 43 moved from here
* DRSTR2 44 moved from here

DEF 85

DOCTOR STRANGE II/DR. STEPHEN VINCENT STRANGE/"STEPHEN SANDERS"
DRSTR2 41
DRSTR2 42
UX 135
DRSTR2 42
* DRSTR2 43 moved here
* DRSTR2 44 moved here

DEF 69
DEF 70
DEF 71
DEF 72
DEF 73
DEF 74
DEF 75
DEF 78
DEF 79
DEF 80
DEF 81
DEF 82
DEF 83
DEF 84
* DRSTR2 43 moved from here
* DRSTR2 44 moved from here

UX@ 4

WONG
DRSTR2 39
* DRSTR2 43 moved here
* DRSTR2 44 moved here

DEF 71
DEF 78
DEF 80-BTS
* DRSTR2 43 moved from here
* DRSTR2 44 moved from here

DRSTR2 45
Michael
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1352
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 10:41 am

Re: miscellaneous minor misplacements part 2

Post by Michael »

michel wrote:SPIDER-MAN/PETER BENJAMIN PARKER
ASM 180
* M/TU 76 moved here
* M/TU 77 moved here

T 271
PPTSS 12-15
M/TU 71
PPTSS 16-20
DEF 61
ASM 182-185
PPTSS 21
M/TU 72
DD2 69-FB
PPTSS 22-23
ASM 185/2
ASM 186
M/TU 73
PPTSS 24
M/TU 74
M/TU 75
* M/TU 76 moved from here
* M/TU 77 moved from here

M/TU 78

WATSON-PARKER, MARY JANE
ASM 179
* M/TU 76 moved here
ASM 182
ASM 183
PPTSS 21
PPTSS 23
PPTSS 24
M/TU 74
M/TU 75
* M/TU 76 moved from here
ASM 188
Hold on, michel, I'm not following you. Why do M/TU 76-77 have to be moved back before T 271? I'm not disputing that they have to be moved back before A@ 8 but why do they have to be moved back before T 271?
Locked